top of page

The Most Successful American Skier of All Time

Writer: Emma Bowen
Emma Bowen
Jun 7, 2020
7 min read

Quite a title, isn't it. This is the phrase I kept on coming across while I've been finding out about Lindsey Vonn - not the best women skier or most successful female, but best American downhill skier ever. Pretty impressive.


The more I found out, the more impressed I became!


The idea for this post came from an interview I saw with Vonn years ago on TV. Clare Balding was speaking to her, and I think it must have been the 2010 winter Olympics in Vancouver. Vonn was dominating the sport so much that the BBC had put together a montage which they described as 'The Vonn Show' to the theme tune from 'The One Show' - I'm sure you can imagine. Goodness knows why I remember that ten years later. The main thing that stuck in my mind though was Vonn talking about how she would like the opportunity to compete against the men, to stretch herself and see how she compared. And I wondered if she ever had. (I bet you can guess the answer).


Vonn only retired in 2019 after a career spanning 20 years, which included periods of incredible success interspersed with injuries, rehab, and seemingly endless comebacks.


Like a lot of athletes, reading about her early life makes you realise how important circumstance and luck play in the great becoming great. When she was nine she told her dad she wanted to be an Olympic skier, and her dad (having competed at a high level himself as a teenager until an injury put an end to his burgeoning career) took her seriously and made a plan. The whole family uprooted to Vail in Colorado to allow her to fulfill her potential. She's an incredible woman and I'm not trying to take anything away from that, but it does make you wonder how many other kids, male or female, could be great at something given the right conditions.





By the time she was 16 Vonn joined the US ski team, and she competed in her first Olympics the following year in 2002. She missed out on the 2006 Olympics after a crash, but went on to win the World Cup in 2008, 2009, 2010 and 2012 as well as one gold and one bronze medals at the Olympics I remember watching in Vancouver in 2010, and another bronze in PyongChange in 2018.


There were no medal for Vonn at the Sochi Olympics in 2014 as she couldn't compete due to injury and over the course of her career she's suffered some pretty terrible accidents - have a look for her crashes on YouTube if you can bear to watch. Yet she describes her favourite aspect of the sport as being the adrenaline rush, and has said that crashing is just part of the job - and that it was worth it because she loved skiing so much.


By the time she was entering what was to be her final season in the winter of 2018-19 she was 34, and the intensity of what she had put her body though was really taking it's toll. She's had four surgeries on her right knee and has torn her ACL, the ligament that attaches the shin to the thigh bone at the knee. Which sounds like it would be fairly crucial for skiing where you are basically squatting the while time and your knees are doing a lot of work! She said that there were so many things wrong with her that it 'was like a game of whack-a-mole' - as soon as one problem seemed to be sorted something else always popped up. Despite this, she was determined to race for one final season.


In her career so far Vonn had won 82 world cup races. The previous record for a woman was 62. The all time record was held by the Swede Ingamar Stenmark, who had won 86. And Vonn was determined to try and beat the record, and she knew that due to her age and injuries, especially the state of her right knee, time was running out.


The story of her 2018-19 season is told in a documentary by HBO called Lindsey Vonn - The Final Season and is an inspiring watch. It shows the agonies she goes through deciding to finally hang up her skis for the last time, not only for herself but for everyone who has supported her and worked with her along the way. She never did take Stenmark's record, but set many many others, including being the oldest woman to win a medal at the world championships when she was 32.


But did she ever race against the men? No. She trained with male athletes, and she also skied on men's skis after her ski technician suggested she tried fellow athlete Bode Miller's skis. Men's skis are longer and stiffer and the assumption always was that a woman wouldn't be able to use them, but as Vonn says in the documentary 'women are capable of using men's skis, it's just no-one had ever thought of it before'. And it only made her faster. But she never did get permission to compete against the men.


She has said in interviews that she has nothing against women's skiing, but that she just wanted to be able to compete against the best, to continue to push her limits and to see how she compared. And my first thought, when I heard her say this back in Vancouver in 2010, was 'well that makes sense, it sounds like a great idea, why not?'


She first applied to the International Ski Federation for permission to compete in a men's race in 2012. She wanted to race the men at Lake Louise in Canada, where the women were also due to race a few days later. Looking at the times from the equivalent race the year before, she would have placed 64th (3rd from last) in the men's race. The response from the governing body was no, because the rules stated that no competitor was allowed to train on a course in the five days leading up to a race, and entering the men's race would have been classed as training for the women's.


The next reference I could find to Vonn pursuing this was in 2017, when she again submitted a request to the International Ski Federation to compete against men. They were supposed to vote on her request at their meeting on May 16th, but it was tabled indefinitely.


Now the more I've thought about this over the last few days, the less clear cut it seems to have become. Initially it seemed obvious - she's beaten all the women, so let her have a go with the men. But then I thought about it a bit more, and came up with some objections. Let's imagine she really did come 64th in the 2011 downhill race at Lake Louise. What about the two men she beat? Is it fair that they are pushed even further down the rankings? And more crucially, does that then give them the right to compete against the women, and probably win? The idea of a woman being allowed to enter a male race and lose (or almost lose) sort of seems fine, but the thought of a man entering the women's race and winning is pretty unacceptable to me. But if the best women can opt to compete against the men, why shouldn't the least - best men be able to opt to compete against the women? Tricky.


Then I thought about just mixing everyone up, having men and women together but racing in different tiers or classes based on speed, or performance, or height/body weigh or some other measure that someone who knows more about these things than me can decide on. A bit like in para-sports, where lots of people compete in the same sport, but against people in their own class based on their abilities. But then, nature would take it's course and the top tier would be very predominantly men, with the odd Vonn competing against them and not doing very well, and most of the women would be in the lower tiers. And even if you tried to say that all the classes/tier were of equal importance (think of weight classes in boxing maybe), in reality the fastest tier would get all the funding and publicity and female athletes would lose out.


Another problem I thought was this. If the very very best female athletes are allowed to opt to compete in male races, then this would become the aim. A prestige higher than winning women's races. Which would reinforce the idea that women's sport is inferior and that men's is harder, faster, better, more exciting. More worth watching, and more worth funding. If the aim of the top female athletes was to race against men, it would devalue the women's races, which is exactly what we don't want.


Having said all that, I can imagine that it was frustrating for Vonn. At the times in her career when she seemed to be winning everything, especially given how competitive she was, she must have craved a real challenge. It's a nice problem to have (not one I've ever had to deal with!) but I can see where she was coming from. But in the interests of gender equality, the top men don't have anywhere else to go when they are at the top of their game, so why should she be any different?


Now I will say I don't have any expert knowledge (or any at all really) in this area, but I've just been thinking over the hypothetical scenarios and this is what I've come up with. If anyone has a solution, answers on a postcard please! Or in the comments below, if you like.




Notes: There's a biography of Vonn here https://www.britannica.com/biography/Lindsey-Vonn and Wikipedia has one too.


Articles discussing her requests to compete in men's races can be found here:




The HBO documentary is on YouTube here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyGY5zD7ytY

(I did try to watch it more 'officially' on Amazon Prime but it's only available in America!)






 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page