top of page

Dipping a Toe into the History of Football

Writer: Emma Bowen
Emma Bowen
Jun 3, 2020
6 min read

While wondering where to start with researching the history of women's sport (considering that my usual first stop, the library, isn't an option at the moment) I conveniently came across a podcast titled 'The History of Football'. So that seemed like a good place to begin!


This was an episode of the 'You're Dead to Me' podcast which is a very good, and very funny history podcast by Greg Jenner, who describes himself as 'chief nerd' on the Horrible Histories TV show, and as 'putting the lols in Lollards'. I love a good geeky joke. I've listened to quite a few and Greg tends to discuss topics outside of the usual 'kings and queens' history, often looking at social or cultural history and subjects from historically marginalised groups. His guests tend to be fairly diverse and representative as well. So when I pressed play I was partly thinking 'hmm, history of football, will this all be about the fellas' but I was hopeful that the women's game would get a look in as well. I didn't really want this post to just be a moan about women being left out of history once again!


So when Greg introduced his first guest as 'she' I was pleased, but not surprised. And then slightly nervous that the fella might not get a look in after all!


She turned out to be Professor Jean Williams, a professor of sport from the University of Wolverhampton, and the other guest was comedian Tom Parry. And the podcast was so interesting I listened to it once while I was out running, and then again the next day so I could take notes! I'll try not to just repeat the whole thing here and just discuss the most interesting points, but you can listen to it in full on BBC Sounds.


So down to business. They discussed the origins of football, that unruly game where whole villages got together to kick a pigs bladder from one end of town to the other, and apparently often ended up stabbing each other in the process. I learned that Henry VIII owned the first pair of purposely-made football boots. Greg and his guests also discussed the class aspect to football, and how it went from being a folk game to something played in public schools to the Saturday afternoon entertainment of the urban working classes. The class angle was really interesting, but out of my remit!


About 30 minutes in, after talking about the association between football and masculinity (also fascinating but also for a different blog, or at least a different article) Greg said 'let's talk about the women's game' and I though 'about time too!'.


This podcast was from September 2019 so just after the Women's World Cup last year, which brought women's football to everyone's attention, including my own, more than ever before. That image of Megan Rapinoe, captain of the USA team, with her arms proudly outstretched after scoring again against France still gives me goosebumps. Her smile seems to say 'I did it!' but also 'I knew I could do it, we told you we could do it! Why are you all so surprised that we can do it?'.


Professor Jean Williams kicked off (sorry) by confirming that in folk football (by which I think she means the old 'pigs bladder' style games as well as casual kickabouts) there have always been women's games and that the women's game is as old as the men's, so really we should just call it football! Which is a great sentiment, but to be honest if I was going to put the telly on to watch a match (which is unusual I'll admit but happens on special occasions) I would want to know if I was going to watch women's or men's. So my suggestion would be instead of having 'football' and 'women's football', we have 'men's football' and 'women's football'. We need to stop assuming (in football and in life) that being male is always the default position unless stated otherwise!


Some factoids about women's football then:

  • The first organised match in front of paying crowds was played in Edinburgh in 1881.

  • The British Ladies Football Club was founded in 1894 and the secretary was the wonderfully named Nettie Honeyball

  • In the USA football (or soccer) was always seen as more suitable for girls in comparison to American football, so it was common for ladies to play and became accepted as a woman's sport. Which is probably why the USA team are so very good, they've got a longer history of being allowed to play and being taken seriously than anyone else.

  • In 1921 there were 150 women's teams in the UK, including the Dick, Kerr Ladies team who the National Football Museum say were the most successful women's team of all time.

  • And then in 1921 the Football Association in the UK banned women's football, and the rest of the world pretty much followed suit.

Where did it all go wrong? I suppose to understand just how much of a big deal the ban was, we need to know how much of a big deal women's football was.


According to Professor Jean, who knows her stuff, the big increase in woman and girls taking up football was due to the changes forced upon society by the First World War. Many many men either volunteered or were conscripted to join the army, and left their jobs and their homes to fight. Women had to take up the slack at home, entering into industries that would previously have been totally off limits. With a move from domestic work as servants to factory work, women gained independence and also an increase in leisure time. And as well as taking on their brothers, husbands and father's jobs, some of them also stepped into their football boots.


Lots of factories, munitions factories in particular, had their own teams, the most famous of which was the Dick, Kerr Ladies team captained by Lily Parr. Parr sounds like she was a legend in her own lifetime, she was known for her strength and power on the pitch, and for having a hearty appetite and smotking like a chimney off it!


In December 1920 a match between the Dick, Kerr Ladies and St Helens Ladies at Goodison Park attracted a paying crowd of 53,000. To put that into context, the average number of spectators for an Everton (who play at Goodison Park) match in the 2018-19 season was 39,362. So it was a pretty big deal.


And then came the ban. The FA decided that football was 'unsuitable' for women, despite a panel of doctors confirming after watching a match that playing football was 'no more taxing than a day's heavy washing'. The FA also complained that the (very famous and admired) female players were taking too high payments for their expenses - i.e. that they were being paid to play football as professionals. Presumably this was seen as a threat the the male players returning from the war, and the ban came into force. And Lily Parr and her fellow sportswomen were expected to hang up their boots and get back to their needlework.


Parr doesn't seem to have been one for needlework though. After the ban she went on tour with the Dick, Kerr Ladies to the USA, where they were expecting to play teams from ladies' colleges. However it wasn't deemed appropriate for the genteel ladies of the US of A to be playing against these powerful factory girls from Lancashire, so Dick, Kerr ladies played nine matches against professional male sides instead! And they held their own in a prefect demonstration of gender equality winning three, losing three and drawing three.


The ban persisted though, and it was only in the 1970s that FIFA started to relieve the ban due to increasing interest in women's football, and in the UK the FA didn't really start to promote it until the 2000s.


I think the comeback that women's football has made is something for me to put on my list of things to find out more about, but it's been fascinating listening to and reading about the glory days of the 1910s and early 20s.


And although I was getting a bit ansty when Greg Jenner didn't introduce the topic of women's football until two thirds of the way through his podcast, it was actually a great idea. (Almost like he's a top-notch professional broadcaster and public historian who knows exactly what he's doing, while I've been writing a blog for less than a week!) Because by ending with the story of the 1921 ban and how the glorious girl's game was stifled for decades, this became the headline story that I was left with when the podcast ended. Tom Parry, the second guest on the pod summed it up really. He said that the story of the women's game 'is an amazing story that isn't known', and that the ban is 'the FA's shame'. He ended by saying 'the bombshell of how we've treated the women's game - that's worth more investigating'.


I couldn't agree more.




Notes:

You can listen to the full podcast here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p07n8q35


I found out more about Lily Parr and the Dick, Kerr ladies from Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lily_Parr) and the National Football Museum (https://www.nationalfootballmuseum.com/halloffame/lily-parr/)


Professor Jean Williams' details are here https://www.wlv.ac.uk/about-us/our-staff/jean-williams/


And my fact about the number of spectators at Everton games is from www.statista.com






Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page